C# · Dotnet

Generic method to avoid long IF clauses

Dear Reader,

Recently at work, i was working with a library which had lot of properties wherein they must be verified for its Truth value before exporting or importing respective attributes to file or back to UI respectively.

Basically, the raw code initially looked roughly like below:

void ExampleMethod() {
SomeType type = new SomeType();

if (type.HasValue1)
  //Export Value1
if (type.HasValue2)
  //Export Value2
if (type.HasValue3)
  //Export Value3
if (type.HasValue4)
  //Export Value4
if (type.HasValue5)
  //Export Value5
if (type.HasValue6)
  //Export Value6
if (type.HasValue7)
  //Export Value7
if (type.HasValue8)
  //Export Value8
if (type.HasValue9)
  //Export Value9
if (type.HasValue10)
  //Export Value10
if (type.HasValue11)
  //Export Value11
if (type.HasValue12)
  //Export Value12

if (type.HasValue25)
  //Export Value25

The above case got repetitive at many places for other types in the same library based on level of their appearance in the UI viz. tree level node. The body of the if-clause all over the place remained same i.e 1 – Check for Truth, 2 – if success, Add to some final list for exporting/importing if not already present.

The method complexity in some cases went over 20 which was getting really gruesome to me. Finally, i decided to refactor the code to reduce not just the complexity but also find a unified solution for other basic types if need be.

Struck to me are 2 possible yet simple solutions yet satisfying the required criteria.

Solution 1: To use the Dictionary<Func< T >, SomeType>, but the body of all those if clauses required another 3rd parameter which hindered me to not opt the dictionary since Dictionary can’t have more than Key : Value pair thus making me to add dictionary inside dictionary which is not only complex in readability aspects but also Value dictionary may not be unique as well. So i had to discard this solution.

Solution 2: To make use of Generic Methods with delegates via lambda expression. This proved to be a working solution in this case yet very simple and effective.

void CheckAndDoSomething < T > (Func< T > property, object Value,
object otherValue) where T: struct
  Type t = typeof(T);
  if (t is bool && property())
     //Do some thing with Value and OtherValue

void ExampleMethod()
  SomeType type = new SomeType();
CheckAndDoSomething(() => type.HasValue1,value0, otherValue0);
CheckAndDoSomething(() => type.HasValue2,value1, otherValue1);
CheckAndDoSomething(() => type.HasValue3,value2, otherValue2);


Hope it helps,
Zen 🙂


Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s